"Head,
Heart and Soul: Mental health problem or spiritual crisis?",
Catharine Stott talks to Catherine Lucas, The Spark newspaper,
June-Sept 2005, No.41, p30, reproduced with permission
When I lived on
booze and drugs, people would yell my name from behind my left ear as I was
going to sleep. I wondered if I was going mad. One day, in rehab, another voice
told me I’d been given a whole new life. My attitude changed from self-pity to
willingness. A psychic said those voices were spirits trying to get my
attention. It was good to know they were more than chemically-induced psychosis.
Psychiatry, on the other hand, isn’t traditionally noted for seeing a
spiritual side to mental health problems, as Catherine Lucas, one of the
organisers of the second annual Revisisoning Mental Health conference at
Hawkwood College in Stroud, explains.
“Spiritual experiences, whether through recreational drugs, meditation or a
mental health experience, are powerful because they can give meaning to our
lives, but practitioners tend to see spiritual experiences as just another
symptom,” she says.
Things are changing however. The Royal College of Psychiatrists has about 900
psychiatrists signed up to its recently formed special interest group on
spirituality and mental health. The Mental Health Foundation and the National
Institute of Mental Health for England are running a three-year project on
spirituality and mental health.
Most of us go through a spiritual emergence or awakening at some stage: a gentle
shift from material concerns to a desire to help others and be of service. But
sometimes this process speeds up and gets out of hand, and the emergence becomes
an crisis, or ‘emergency’, a term coined by Stan Grof, a founder of
transpersonal pyschology. Symptoms include: difficulty distinguishing the inner
visionary world from daily reality; trouble coping with everyday life (because
bombarded with inner experiences); intense emotions, visions and other sensory
changes, and unusual thoughts.
Adds Catherine , “Grof says that aspects of a spiritual emergency look like
psychosis, and because the two may go hand in hand, the diagnosis can be
tricky.”
Twenty years ago, Catherine, a former lecturer in European Studies, ended up in
a psychiatric ward diagnosed with a psychotic breakdown. She later worked as a
patient’s advocate and trained in Buddhism-based psychotherapy. It was only
five years ago, when reading Grof that she understood what had really been
happening to her. “I had another major crisis two years ago. My mind was
desparately trying to create meaning about what I was experiencing. This,
coupled with the terror I was feeling, resulted in the mind creating paranoid
thoughts. The psychiatrist was keen to prescribe pretty heavy-duty
anti-psychotic drugs. But I preferred to use mild tranquilisers and mindfulness
to manage the fear and so dissipate the paranoid thoughts. I watched my
thoughts, saying ‘I am experiencing fear but I am not my fear.”
Mindfulness is a method of observing one’s thoughts and feelings as they arise
without judgement. “People tend to come out of spiritual crises with a greatly
enhanced quality of life because their values have changed and their role in
society can be very positive,” says Catherine. As a direct result of her
experience, she and friend John Fotheringhame put on a conference at Hawkwood
College on A Mindfulness-Based Approach to Spiritual Emergency.
She says: “This year’s conference, Working With Spiritual Crisis, is an
opportunity to explore their own or their clients’ issues around their issues
of spiritual emergence(y) in a workshop setting.” The speakers are: David
Lukoff, an American psychologist who got a new diagnosis of ‘religious or
spiritual problem’ into the psychiatrists’ diagnostic manual DSM IV; Barbara
Stones, who uses Family Systems Constellation Work for issues such as psychosis
and trauma; and Rosamund Oliver, a spiritual care educator, working with loss,
death and illness.
Riding out spiritual emergencies requires self-awareness and support from the
right people, and to this end Catherine is involved in setting up a national
Spiritual Crisis Network. Catherine says, “We’re connecting with people from
all over the country, so if someone calls they can be in touch with sympathetic
people in their area, including someone with personal experience, and a mental
health professional. In the meantime we’re building a website (not ready as
Spark went to press) to put information on: about books, articles, local
networks and videos.”